Esfir Shub (1894-1959)

Alias:
Esther Il'inichna Shub
Эсфирь Шуб

Birthplace:
Surazh, Russian Empire

Born:
March 16, 1894

Died:
September 21, 1959

Esfir Shub, also referred to as Esther Il'inichna Shub, was a pioneering Soviet filmmaker and editor in both the mainstream and documentary fields. She was one of few women to play a significant role behind the scenes in the Soviet film industry. She is best known for her trilogy of films, Fall of the Romanov Dynasty (1927), The Great Road (1927), and The Russia of Nicholas II and Leo Tolstoy (1928). Shub is credited as the creator of compilation film.  Esfir Shub was born into a family of landowners. She studied literature in Moscow, but after Revolution she began to attend the classes at the Institute for Women's Higher Education and then got a job as a 'theater officer' at the State Commissariat of Education. In the theatre she worked in collaboration with the famous avant-garde director Meyerhold and the poet Mayakovsky, who was one of her friends.  Shub joined the Goskino film company and met Dziga Vertov. Their professional friendship was lifelong, but stormy. Shub shared his belief in film's intrinsic ability to reveal aspects of reality not visible to the naked eye, but she became engaged more in the interpretation of the historical world than in only contemporary matters.  First Shub worked as a re-editor of foreign films for Soviet distribution. In 1927 (the tenth anniversary of Revolution) she made her first documentary film The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty (1927). This film was the first part of the trilogy, which also consists of The Great Road (1927) and Lev Tolstoy and the Russia of Nicolai II (1928). In the process of making the trilogy, Shub had to contend with not only an overwhelming volume of material but also the problem of locating relevant footage. She often found that valuable documents of the pre-war period had been sold abroad or had been badly damaged in ill-equipped newsreel archives. Shub compensated the lack of material by using newly shot footage. Her films derive much of their power from this technique of providing a contemporary context for archival footage. Thus, Shub created the absolutely new genre 'historical compilation film'. She later claimed she just wanted to create 'editorialized newsreels'.  The critics and colleagues admired Shub's work, because she found a middle path between narrative and documentary forms. Sovkino denied her authorial rights for her trilogy claiming that she was just an editor. However, in 1935 Shub was awarded the title Honored Artist of the Republic.  In the beginning of the forties she collaborated with Vsevolod Pudovkin on the successful Twenty Years of Soviet Cinema (1940). Then she left Goskino to become chief editor of the 'News of the Day' at the central studio for documentary film in Moscow. Most of her later years were confined to editing duties. Shub was definitely the most prominent Soviet woman filmmaker of her generation.

Additional information:

The Search Form


Directing Lighting Artist:
1929  Hoy ( Segodnya )

Director:
1927  The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty
1927  The Great Road
1928  Lev Tolstoy and the Russia of Nicolai II
1929  Hoy ( Segodnya )
1929  Today
1932  The Komsomol - Chief of Electrification
1937  Turkey at the Turning Point
1939  Spain
1942  Native Land
1947  On the Other Side of the Araks

Editor:
1926  Abrek Zaur
1926  Wings of a Serf
1927  Prostitute
1927  The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty
1927  The Gentlefolks of Skotinin
1927  The Great Road
1928  Lev Tolstoy and the Russia of Nicolai II
1929  Hoy ( Segodnya )
1929  Today
1932  The Komsomol - Chief of Electrification
1937  Turkey at the Turning Point
1939  Spain
1942  Native Land
1947  On the Other Side of the Araks

Scenario Writer:
1926  Abrek Zaur
1926  Wings of a Serf
1927  Prostitute
1927  The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty
1927  The Gentlefolks of Skotinin
1927  The Great Road
1928  Lev Tolstoy and the Russia of Nicolai II
1929  Hoy ( Segodnya )
1929  Today
1932  The Komsomol - Chief of Electrification
1937  Turkey at the Turning Point
1939  Spain
1942  Native Land
1947  On the Other Side of the Araks

Writer:
1926  Abrek Zaur
1926  Wings of a Serf
1927  Prostitute
1927  The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty
1927  The Gentlefolks of Skotinin
1927  The Great Road
1928  Lev Tolstoy and the Russia of Nicolai II
1929  Hoy ( Segodnya )
1929  Today
1932  The Komsomol - Chief of Electrification
1937  Turkey at the Turning Point
1939  Spain
1942  Native Land
1947  On the Other Side of the Araks

About the Movie Section

Most data and links to images for the Movies section come from TheMovieDB (TMDB).

Additional data for Film Titles come from The Open Movie Database (OMDb).

At least one plug-in comes from IMDb.

Data are -- hey, it's a plural -- subject to the limitations of their sources. (For example, TMDB search results currently max out at 20.) I am limiting myself to free data sources for now. (No, a "free trial" is not free.)

While much of the above data are retrieved directly from outside APIs and other such sources, data from American Film Institute (AFI) and British Film Institute (BFI) were manually entered the old fashioned way into a MySQL database. Re BFI I took the following liberties:

  • I added "runners up" to Top 10 lists, treating them as ties where applicable and numbering them accordingly at the bottom of each list.
  • Regarding those polls wherein "franchise" movies were submitted as one project until BFI's policy changed to regard them separately, I treated them as ties and renumbered the affected lists accordingly (e.g. the Godfather films).

Regarding profile removals and data corrections:

  • If you would like your profile removed from this site, please contact the source of this data directly, TheMovieDB. My assumption is: once it's gone from their site, it should soon be gone from this site.
  • If you would like to correct movie data on this site, please contact the source of this data directly, TheMovieDB. My assumption is: once it's corrected on their site, it should soon be corrected on this site.
  • For additional corrections and profile removals, please e-mail The Open Movie Database (OMDb).

Filtering is applied here to film projects flagged as "adult" by TheMovieDB. Pending "popular demand" I am contemplating a login and profile system with preferences (such as whether to allow adult images to appear) and permissions (such as data entry).

Whereas the overall purpose of this website is to serve as a personal demo/portfolio/workshop of web and data skills, this Movies section is not meant to compete with or substitute for far more definitive movie websites.

Whether or not he still clings to an award which he won in 1986 as a film critic for his college's newspaper, Jeffrey Hartmann is not responsible for the texts of overviews and biographies supplied by external data sources.